The Gold TOGA is presented to the Best Original Group Game or Variation. This award debuted at the Inaugural award ceremony.
| Ceremony | Award | Winner |
| Innaugural TOGAs June/July 2011 |  |
Survivor USA vs The World hosted by Yankeeman311  |
| 2nd TOGAs August 2011 |  |
The Cage 3 hosted by Jubbzy  |
| 3rd TOGAs September 2011 |
The Climb - Season 1 hosted by Thedarkpassanger  | |
| 4th TOGAs October/November 2011 |
RSF Season 10: The Castle hosted by RShowFreak  | |
| 5th TOGAs June 2012 |  |
Survivor Idol Wars hosted by Mearl  |
| 6th TOGAs July 2012 |
The Glass House hosted by Kpnna  | |
| 7th TOGAs August 2012 |
Secret Story 5 hosted by Koolmanmadden  | |
| 8th TOGAs September 2012 |
Masterchef Season 1 hosted by chocolatejer  | |
| 9th TOGAs October 2012 |
Survivor Return to Bouvet Island hosted by Gaiaphage  | |
| 10th TOGAs November 2012 |
Tengaged (Karaoke) Idol 7: The X-Factor hosted by TolisKalkas  | |
| 11th TOGAs December 2012 |
TTRS 12: Legends of the Hidden Temple hosted by Turney1805  | |
| 12th TOGAs January 2013 |
The World's Longest Group Game hosted by Zimdelinvasor  | |
| 13th TOGAs February 2013 |
The Bachelorette hosted by Brogs17  |
